The following describes incidents that happened immediately prior to three fire-side explosions of industrial plant boilers. The cause of these light-off problems and the lessons learned apply to all types of fuel-fired equipment.
Three separate industrial water tube boilers experienced fire-side explosions with boilers with a capacity of 20,000 to 40,000 pph and operated at 90 to 100 psig pressure. The explosions destroyed one boiler and damaged three others, fortunately no injuries were reported. The incidents came after the three boilers experienced trouble lighting-up, had fuel/air ratio, or burner capacity problems.
LESSONS TO LEARN
Recognize obvious danger signs and take actions to avoid explosions before they occur. Three very important take-aways from this article are your ability to recognize danger signs that may sound like this:
- We aren’t getting the steam capacity or the temperature we expected!
- The equipment is hard to start. We had to try and light-up several times!
- There’s smoke and soot coming out of the stack! When the burner ramps up to high fire the flame turns very orange or yellow!
These kinds of situations can mean big trouble. Calling a contractor is not the end of the story. It is very important that the contractor coming to the site has the right skill set and experience. In two of the three explosion cases described above, a contractor service person was at the scene working on the equipment. In one case, the contractor’s service person was at the site the day before.
All three incidents occurred on the equipment’s light-up. It is important that you understand light-up basics to avoid dangerous conditions. The light-up process for boilers and process equipment involves four important key elements, these are:
- The Pre-Purge
Process equipment requires at least 4 air changes of the fire box before an ignition source can be introduced. Multiple burner boilers have a number of issues that must be considered to calculate the proper purge time. Multiple burner boilers must have purge times that are a minimum of 5 minutes. Other boiler air change requirements for purging can be from 4 to 8 air changes depending on a number of factors. In one of the explosions, the purge time was found to be only about half of what it should have been.
- The Pilot Trial for Ignition Period
Pilot systems are allowed 10 seconds to try and light for natural gas and 15 seconds for heavy fuel oil. It should never really take this long. If you’re not getting a pilot lit in 3 or 4 seconds your system needs to be more closely evaluated.
- Low Fire Positioning
Most systems of any size, (i.e. usually 5 million BTU’s per hour input and up), require the main fuel valve to be at a low fire position prior to light off. This usually means somewhere between 15 to 25% of high fire capacity. You’ll have to check with the burner manufacturer to find the correct minimum firing rate for your particular equipment. Only then can a qualified technician make the necessary adjustments. In one of the explosions, the burner was set to light-off at 50% of high fire or about 15,000,000 BTUH. This was a major factor in the boiler’s explosion.
- Main Flame Trial for Ignition Period
Once a pilot is lit and the main gas firing rate control valve is at a minimum position, then the main automatic safety shut-off valves open for a specific amount of time (i.e. the main flame trial for ignition period). This is 10 seconds for gas and 15 seconds for heavy fuel oil. Once again, as in the case of the pilot trial for ignition period, it should never really take 10 or 15 seconds. If you’re not getting a main flame lit in 3 or 4 seconds your system needs to be more closely evaluated.Besides these key factors one should also know a little about pilot systems and how they work.
BASIC TYPES OF PILOT SYSTEMS
Standing Pilots – Are lit all the time just like many home hot water heaters. These are usually used in very small and very old equipment.
Intermittent Pilots – Are on for the entire call for heat (i.e. the entire burner firing cycle). Because of this, a signal from the igniter system could fool the burner management system into thinking that a stable pilot is lit even when it isn’t. This could cause the main fuel valves to open or remain open when they shouldn’t be.
Interruptible Pilots – Allow for the pilot igniter to be open for only 5 of the 10 or 15 second trial for ignition period. If a pilot flame signal is seen after the 10 or 15 second period then it has to be from a legitimate and proper pilot. These types of pilots are required for most process equipment and larger boilers.
There are a number of other issues that are important in understanding pilots and light-ups, including early spark termination systems, pilot spark pick-up tests, hot surface igniters, and self-piloted burners.
- The incidents described did not escalate into major catastrophes in part because the operators were able to quickly get the fuel shut off. Make sure that your manual fuel shut-off valves are operable, marked, and maintained. Our firm offers the sealants and equipment to properly maintain valves, including instructional videos about service techniques.
- Purchase and install fuel valves that have some sort of external position indication. This can help safe light up monitoring.
- When manual for automatic fuel valves are changed out, make sure that the start-up process includes dry firing with fuel “off” to safely verify that fuel valves are set and operating properly.
- Verify that contractors are qualified to perform the required services. Ask about specific manufacturer experience and training. Make sure that qualifications, and not just price, are included in the decision for who to hire for critical interlock and safety testing functions and/or combustion equipment service.
Honeywell Combustion Safety has been in business since 1984. With engineers and staff members that sit on Code committees such as NFPA 56, NFPA 85, NFPA 86, and NFPA 87, our inside expertise is integrated within all of our practices and our global reach ensures that customers around the world are kept safe. Honeywell Combustion Safety offers Testing and Inspections, Engineering & Upgrades/Retrofits, Gas Hazards Management, Training, and Field Services for all industrial facilities and different types of fuel fired equipment. Contact Honeywell Combustion Safety at +1 216.749.2992 or visit www.combustionsafety.com for additional information.